For education and evidence appraisal — not a substitute for clinical judgment.
CertaintyGrade
Evidence Appraisal · Structured Deliberation · EBM Education

From evidence to defensible decisions.

CertaintyGrade helps educators, researchers, and clinicians structure clinical questions, critically appraise evidence, and make transparent certainty judgments — with every conclusion linked to the supporting evidence.

Built by a physician-educator and former Cochrane Clinical Answers editor.

No account required to start

One platform. Three tools.

GRADE is the methodological engine. CertaintyGrade is the reasoning workspace built around it.

⊕

Assess

Appraise and grade evidence

Structure a PICO question, add studies, and produce a transparent GRADE certainty rating with every domain judgment linked to the supporting evidence.

Try a Free Assessment →
⟳

Journal Club

Learn through structured deliberation

Run evidence-based journal clubs for your residency or research group — with assigned positions, AI-assisted worksheets, and an instructor moderator packet.

Create a Session →
◎

Learn

Build EBM competency

Free interactive GRADE tutorial covering all five certainty domains, upgrade and downgrade factors, and the PICO question structure that anchors every assessment.

Start the Tutorial →

The GRADE principle CertaintyGrade enforces

"A paper doesn't have a GRADE rating.
An answer to a specific clinical question does."

The same RCT earns different certainty levels for different questions — because directness, imprecision relative to the decision threshold, and applicability all shift with the question. GRADE is question-anchored by design. CertaintyGrade enforces that discipline.

How GRADE assessment works

1

Define your PICO question

Population · Intervention · Comparison · Outcome. GRADE certainty has no meaning without a clearly specified question and outcome.

2

Add your studies

Paste an abstract, enter a PubMed ID, or paste full text. Multiple studies produce a body-of-evidence rating.

3

Review before running

You confirm the question and study list before the assessment runs. The certainty rating applies to exactly what you specified.

4

Get a transparent, editable GRADE rating

High / Moderate / Low / Very Low certainty, with domain-by-domain rationale citing specific data points. Every judgment is reviewable.

For Educators & Residency Programs

Run structured journal clubs — not just discussions

CertaintyGrade Journal Club assigns participants to supporting or refuting positions, guides them through an evidence-based worksheet with PubMed integration, and generates an AI-assisted Moderator Packet summarizing agreement, disagreement, and teaching points.

📋Structured PICO → evidence worksheet
⚖️Assigned supporting & refuting positions
📦Moderator Packet with AI synthesis

Built on 13 years of Cochrane methodology

CertaintyGrade was built by Adarsh K. Gupta, DO, MS, FACOFP — Associate Editor at Cochrane Clinical Answers since 2012, founding director of a Center for Information Mastery, and clinical AI consultant. The methodology is pilot-benchmarked against published Cochrane GRADE ratings.

13+
Years applying GRADE at Cochrane
90+
Peer-reviewed publications
10+
Cochrane cases pilot-benchmarked

CertaintyGrade is an independent product and is not affiliated with or endorsed by the GRADE Working Group or Cochrane.

Start with a free assessment

No account required. Try the full GRADE workflow on any clinical question.